Bottom line: don't compare unit prices on Cross pens. Compare total cost. I want to say the exact unit prices were $4.16 and $3.82, but don't quote me on those numbers. What I remember clearly is the gap: the “cheaper” quote would have cost about 17% more once I added engraving dies, branded packaging, and freight.
I'm the procurement manager at a 180-person marketing services company. I've managed our corporate gifts and office supplies budget—roughly $40,000 a year—for six years, and every order goes through our purchasing system. I'm not the person who makes the pens. I'm the person who pays for them, which is why I stopped trusting unit price.
The lowest quoted price is rarely the lowest total cost. A pen that sits in a drawer is worth zero, no matter what it costs.
When I audited our 2023 spending, I found that about 14% of the corporate gift budget went to rush freight, setup fees, and reprints—costs that hadn't appeared in the original quotes. That number stuck with me.
What “cross-pens” and “Cross pens president” searches have in common
When someone searches for “cross-pens” or “Cross pens president,” they usually want a pen that carries weight. Sometimes it's a corporate gift. Sometimes it's a request from an executive who wants the presentation to feel serious. I can't verify every historical claim about presidents and pen brands, so I won't. What I can verify from purchase orders is this: those searches tend to mean the recipient is supposed to keep the pen, not throw it in a drawer.
That changes the math. A Cross pen has a real heritage—the company has been making writing instruments since 1846, and many models carry a lifetime warranty. That lifespan matters when you calculate cost per use. A disposable promo pen is cheap per unit, but if it ends up in a landfill after one event, its value went with it.
The Cross Star Wars pens order that changed my process
Last holiday season, marketing requested 300 Cross Star Wars pens for a client appreciation event. My first instinct was to find a cheaper fan-branded pen. Then I got the total cost picture.
The Cross Star Wars pens came in collectible packaging. Recipients kept the boxes. The cheaper alternative arrived in a plain box, and our event coordinator said the same thing I was thinking: nobody was going to keep it. The cheaper pen would have been worse value at any price.
Here's what the order actually included:
- Pens with clip engraving, quoted per unit.
- Custom insert trays, because the standard foam didn't fit the collectible packaging.
- Split-case repacking for two event sites.
- 5% overage for lids that arrived scratched and clips that didn't engrave cleanly.
- Rush freight when one event date moved up.
That last item is what killed the cheap vendor's quote. Their lead time was too long, so we paid rush freight. The vendor with the shorter lead time cost more per pen but none for expediting. Total cost favored the second vendor, even though their unit price was higher.
I'm not a logistics expert, so I can't speak to carrier optimization. What I can tell you from a procurement perspective is to evaluate lead times the same way you evaluate prices.
The photo printer detour
Marketing also wanted a thank-you card in every gift box. Someone suggested buying a photo printer for the office because the process seemed cheaper. It wasn't.
The photo printer was $180. Photo ink cartridges ran about $60 a set, and glossy paper added another $25. That's $265 before the first card. Commercial printing came to $0.21 per card, or about $63 for 300 cards. The cards were printed at 300 DPI, the standard for commercial print. Our print shop matched the card color to the Cross packaging, and I don't remember the exact Delta E number, but it fell within Pantone's defined tolerance for brand-matched color.
A photo printer would've made sense if we had a steady stream of photo jobs. We didn't. It would have sat in the supply closet and become a $265 cost center. The “cheaper” option was actually the opposite of a no-brainer.
Hidden costs I check before every purchase
Here's the short version of my checklist:
- Setup or die charges that show up after you add engraving.
- Repackaging fees for split shipments.
- Freight quotes that don't include event-site access or liftgate delivery.
- Overage requirements that vary by product.
- How hard it is to get a straight answer from the vendor. If I email three times for an invoice, that time is a cost.
Real talk: the vendor with the cheapest quote usually isn't trying to fool me. They just have different assumptions about what “ready to hand out” means. My job is to find out before signing, not after.
Where this approach stops
The total cost mindset isn't a life philosophy. It's a purchasing lens. If you came here from an A1C calculator search, I'm not the right source for medical advice. I track my own numbers, but I'm not a clinician, and a procurement spreadsheet doesn't belong in that conversation.
Same with how to get permanent marker off wood. I can tell you the method I've seen work on finished wood: rubbing alcohol, or tracing over the marker with a dry-erase marker and wiping it off. Test in an inconspicuous spot first. But I'm not a wood-finish specialist, so don't take that as a professional guarantee.
I've also made the classic overconfidence mistake. I skipped the final proof check on a branded pen order once because it was “basically the same as last time.” It wasn't. We caught it before shipping only because a warehouse worker noticed the carton was addressed to the wrong event. That was luck, not process.
There's something satisfying about a buying decision that still looks smart six months later. The Cross Star Wars pens order did what it was supposed to do, the photo printer stayed at the store, and the final invoice came in under budget. That's the whole argument for total cost thinking: getting the outcome you paid for, not just the lowest number on the first page.
The limit of this article
If you're buying 50 pens for a small office, don't build a six-vendor comparison matrix. You'll spend more in time than you'll save in money. A simple checklist—unit price, shipping, setup, turnaround—is enough. My framework matters for recurring purchases, where a hidden 17% gap repeats on every order. That's when “cheap” gets expensive.
Discuss this writing program topic